Battle of the Song Titles: When Rock Legends Clash Over Titles

In the world of rock music, originality is everything — from guitar riffs and lyrics to the artwork and album names. But sometimes, two or more artists end up giving their songs the exact same name, whether by accident or defiant design. These aren’t covers. These are totally different tracks, united by name but often wildly different in sound and style.

In this blog, we pit some of rock’s most recognisable and rebellious tracks against each other in a tongue-in-cheek battle of the song names. Who wins? That’s up to you.

1. “One” – Metallica vs. U2

Two massive bands. Two very different songs. One name.

• Metallica’s “One” (1988): This is a blistering anti-war metal anthem, filled with despair and thunderous double-kick drums. Inspired by Johnny Got His Gun, it's a tale of a wounded soldier trapped in his own body. The track opens with haunting clean guitar before exploding into pure thrash fury — it's intense, political, and unforgettable.

• U2’s “One” (1991): A gentler, emotionally complex ballad, “One” from U2’s Achtung Baby deals with unity, relationships, and healing. It’s more about coming together than being torn apart — the polar opposite of Metallica’s take.

Winner: Tough call. Metallica wins for raw power, U2 for emotional depth. Let’s call this one a draw — depends if you're headbanging or heartbroken.

2. “Alive” – Pearl Jam vs. KISS

• Pearl Jam’s “Alive” (1991): The band’s first single, it introduced Eddie Vedder’s unique vocals and storytelling style to the world. It’s part of a loosely autobiographical trilogy, and although the lyrics explore trauma and confusion, it became an anthem of survival and resilience. That soaring guitar solo? Timeless.

• KISS’s “Alive” (1975): OK, technically Alive! is a live album, not a song. But the band also recorded a track called “Alive” in 2003 on Psycho Circus. It’s all about defiance, rock stardom, and swagger — everything you’d expect from KISS.

Winner: Pearl Jam by a mile. More iconic, more emotional, and arguably one of the best songs of the ‘90s.

3. “Hurricane” – Bob Dylan vs. Thirty Seconds to Mars

• Bob Dylan’s “Hurricane” (1975): This protest song is a searing indictment of racial injustice, telling the story of boxer Rubin "Hurricane" Carter. Dylan’s lyrics are razor-sharp, the violin is frantic, and the delivery is urgent — this is storytelling as protest.

• Thirty Seconds to Mars’ “Hurricane” (2010): Jared Leto’s version is a cinematic, synth-infused rock track full of atmosphere and angst. It’s dramatic, dark, and leans more into emotional and existential turbulence than socio-political commentary.

Winner: Dylan, hands down. His “Hurricane” is a classic that changed minds and made headlines. The Mars track is sleek but lacks the cultural weight.

4. “Stay” – David Bowie vs. Shakespears Sister vs. Rihanna (bonus curveball)

• David Bowie’s “Stay” (1976): A funk-infused, guitar-drenched deep cut from Station to Station, this song features some of Bowie’s slickest grooves and Carlos Alomar’s killer guitar work.

• Shakespears Sister’s “Stay” (1992): A goth-pop powerhouse full of drama and weirdness. It's part power ballad, part eerie opera, and totally unforgettable. The music video alone could give you nightmares.

• Rihanna’s “Stay” (2012): Not rock, but since we’re here — a heart-wrenching, stripped-back ballad that’s become a modern classic.

Winner: Bowie, because funk-era Bowie is criminally underrated. But if you love a good melodramatic moment, Shakespears Sister comes close.

5. “Run” – Foo Fighters vs. Snow Patrol

• Foo Fighters’ “Run” (2017): A late-era banger from the Foos, this track is a loud, aggressive call to arms with heavy riffs and Dave Grohl screaming like it’s 1997. Proof the band still had fire decades into their career.

• Snow Patrol’s “Run” (2003): Emotional, sweeping and cinematic, it’s a tearjerker from their Final Straw album. Often overshadowed by Leona Lewis’ cover, but still a brilliant track in its own right.

Winner: Foo Fighters, purely for volume and ferocity. But if you’re in your feels, Snow Patrol is your guy.

6. “Breathe” – Pink Floyd vs. The Prodigy vs. Faith Hill (yes, really)

• Pink Floyd’s “Breathe” (1973): A dreamy, psychedelic track from Dark Side of the Moon. Full of philosophical musings and atmospheric guitar, it’s a song to get lost in.

• The Prodigy’s “Breathe” (1997): Not rock in the traditional sense, but its punk energy earns it a mention. This is a snarling, hyper-aggressive track with serious attitude.

• Faith Hill’s “Breathe” (1999): Again, not rock — but fascinating how one word can carry such different meanings, from dreamy (Floyd) to frantic (Prodigy) to romantic (Hill).

Winner: Pink Floyd. An undisputed classic. The Prodigy’s track rocks in a different way, but Floyd’s “Breathe” is pure space-age genius.

7. “Black” – Pearl Jam vs. Sevendust

• Pearl Jam’s “Black” (1991): One of the band’s most loved songs, it never had an official single release but remains a fan favourite. It’s a poetic, emotional gut-punch with Eddie Vedder’s voice at its haunting best.

• Sevendust’s “Black” (1997): A full-throttle nu-metal track with thunderous riffs and raw vocals. More about energy and aggression than introspection.

Winner: Pearl Jam again. “Black” is soul-crushing in the best way. Sevendust’s version rocks hard, but lacks the subtlety and emotional pull.

8. “Gravity” – John Mayer vs. Papa Roach vs. Embrace

• Papa Roach’s “Gravity” (2015): A moody alt-rock duet that’s heavier on the pain and angst, touching on addiction and inner demons.

• John Mayer’s “Gravity” (2006): A bluesy, slow-burning ballad that’s as smooth as it is existential. Mayer flexes his guitar and songwriting chops here.

• Embrace’s “Gravity” (2004): A Coldplay-adjacent Brit-rock tune full of longing and uplifting vibes.

Winner: Mayer wins on sheer musicality, but Embrace's version might sneak into your heart if you’re into early 2000s British indie.

9. “Time” – Pink Floyd vs. Ghost

Two legendary bands. Two completely different kinds of darkness.

• Pink Floyd – “Time” (1973)
  A prog-rock masterpiece from Dark Side of the Moon, it opens with eerie ticking clocks before launching into philosophical musings about wasted youth. Hypnotic and harrowing.

• Ghost – “Time” (2022)
  From the Impera album, Ghost’s “Time” is theatrical, melodic, and full of the band’s signature doom-pop drama. Less existential dread, more gothic grandeur.

Winner: Floyd takes it on legacy alone — but Ghost puts up a stylish fight.

10. “Paranoid” – Black Sabbath vs. Kanye West

• Black Sabbath – “Paranoid” (1970): The one, the only. Proto-metal masterpiece. Simple, powerful, and still makes your heart race over 50 years later. If your kid’s rocking our Sabbath tee, they’re already ahead of the curve.

• Kanye West – “Paranoid” (2008): Not a rock track, but a catchy synth-pop cut from 808s & Heartbreak. Slick, but very different.

Winner: Sabbath invented heavy metal with this track. No contest. Black Sabbath wins in leather and eyeliner.

11.“Alive” – Pearl Jam vs. Avenged Sevenfold

• Pearl Jam – “Alive” (1991): One of grunge’s defining moments. Heartfelt, raw, and lifted by one of the best guitar solos of the ‘90s. A heavy song that became an anthem of resilience.

• Avenged Sevenfold – “Alive” (2005): A deep cut from City of Evil, less well-known, but full of their signature shredding and theatrical metal vibes.

Winner: Pearl Jam, by a landslide. Their “Alive” is untouchable.

12.“The End” – The Doors vs. The Beatles vs. My Chemical Romance

• The Doors – “The End” (1967): Eleven minutes of psychedelic doom, Oedipal nightmares, and whispered menace. Not exactly nursery material, but a legendary piece of rock weirdness.

• The Beatles – “The End” (1969): The final track recorded by all four Beatles together. Short, sweet, and philosophical: “And in the end, the love you take is equal to the love you make.”

• My Chemical Romance – “The End.” (2006): An operatic opening to The Black Parade. Theatrical, emo, dramatic as hell.

Winner: The Beatles win for sentiment. MCR wins for eyeliner. The Doors win for trauma. Everyone wins. Everyone loses. It’s the end.

Conclusion: Same Name, Different Legends

What’s in a name? Apparently, a lot — or nothing at all. These songs may share titles, but they take completely different journeys. Whether it’s political rage, emotional heartbreak, raw power or smooth groove, the title is only the tip of the iceberg.

It’s a reminder that in music, context is everything. One word can birth a dozen meanings, each shaped by the artist behind it. So next time you search a song title and get more than you bargained for, don’t skip — dive in. You might just discover your new favourite track under a very familiar name.

Got a favourite “title twin” we didn’t mention? Let us know! After all, in the battle of the song names, everyone has a dog in the fight.

🔥 Want your kid to wear the bands that battle it out? From Nirvana to Metallica, Slipknot to Queen — check out our full range of officially licensed kids' band tees at KidVicious.co.uk